Philosophy & religion

You Can, If You Want To: Navigating Christian Faith, Conscience, and matters LGBTQ+

by James Alison

You Can, If You Want To is a book about basic Christianity.

The story

You Can, If You Want To is a book about basic Christianity. Written by a Catholic priest and theologian who is also a gay man, it sets out a fairly rigorous, conservative account of how Creation and Redemption work, and shows why being open, straightforward and affirming with LGBTQ+ children, friends, colleagues and selves flows naturally from that faith rather than being a piece of special pleading.

Only in an addendum does Alison turn to the handful of biblical “clobber texts”, by which point many readers, especially Protestant readers on whom those passages weigh most heavily, will find they no longer carry the weight they once did.

For anyone who has wrestled with conscience over LGBTQ+ inclusion in their church, and for gay Christians who have been told they must choose.

The first page

Introduction

This is a book about basic Christianity. One written by a Catholic priest and theologian who, as is not uncommon in his profession, is a gay man.

For some of you the words ‘Catholic’ or ‘priest’ may raise hackles; for others the word ‘gay’ may do the same. And for some of you the three terms applied to the same person may seem some sort of contradiction in logic: something that just shouldn’t be.

My hope is that by the end of the book, and perhaps especially, but by no means only, if you’re Protestant and straight, my self-description will seem unimportant, and you will have found your appreciation for your Christian faith enhanced.

Some of you, as you have sought to live the fullness of faith, may have had worries of conscience about accepting the full humanity of LGBTQ+ people, or indeed some other group, within the life of our churches. I pray that it will become obvious to you how an ability to move on in this field flows naturally from what I will share with you: a fairly rigorous, conservative account of how our Creation and Redemption in Christ works.

Let me start with an analogy: that of the detective story.

About the author

James Alison, short grey hair, in a green cable-knit jumper

James Alison

James Alison is a Catholic theologian, priest and author. He has studied, lived and worked in Mexico, Brazil, Bolivia, Chile, Spain and the United States as well as his native England. James earned his doctorate in theology from the Jesuit Faculty in Belo Horizonte, Brazil in 1994 and is a systematic theologian by training.

He is known for his firm but patient insistence on truthfulness in all matters gay as an ordinary part of basic Christianity, and for his pastoral outreach in the same sphere.

James now works as an itinerant preacher, lecturer and retreat giver. He is currently a Fellow of Imitatio. He accompanies a wide variety of publics, through academic lectures, undergraduate, postgraduate and professors seminars, adult catechesis courses, retreats for priests, parish groups, and Catholic and ecumenical gay and lesbian retreats.

Author’s Website (opens in a new tab)

Reader reviews

Read it? Give it some stars and tell the next reader what they're in for.